Tim Allen’s New Show Just Locked in Season 3 and the Numbers Explain Why

Proxima Studio image via Shutterstock

ABC canceled Tim Allen's hit sitcom Last Man Standing back in 2017.

Tim Allen went back to ABC anyway, and this time he built a new hit from scratch.

That show just earned a Season 3 return date and the viewership to explain exactly why.

ABC Canceled Last Man Standing and Fox Turned It Into a Hit

Tim Allen had already lived through one ABC cancellation before Shifting Gears ever existed.

ABC pulled the plug on Last Man Standing after six seasons in May 2017, even though it was the network's second-most-watched comedy at the time.

ABC Entertainment President Channing Dungey said the network was done airing comedies on Friday nights.

Then ABC moved Fresh Off the Boat, a show that ranked 10th out of ABC's 11 sitcoms, into that exact same slot.

Asked directly whether Allen's politics played a role in the cancellation, Dungey said that was not "the deciding factor."

Fox News called that answer a "non-denial denial."

Fans launched an ABC boycott petition and pushed to bring the show back.

Fox picked the show up for a seventh season, and it ran there for three more years.

Twitter lit up with posts calling the revival a way to "Make TV Great Again."

Shifting Gears Gave ABC Its Best Sitcom Launch Since 2018

Shifting Gears premiered on ABC in January 2025.

Tim Allen plays Matt, a widowed classic-car shop owner whose estranged daughter moves back home with her kids.

The premiere pulled in 16.95 million total viewers across every platform in its first seven days.

That was a 173 percent jump over its initial same-day audience.

It was ABC's strongest series launch since The Conners in 2018.

It also became the most-watched ABC series premiere in the network's streaming history.

Season 2 closed out in February 2026 on a cliffhanger, with Riley torn between two men.

The finale still pulled 6.9 million viewers across platforms.

ABC just locked in Season 3 for a two-episode premiere on January 6, 2027, paired with the Season 9 premiere of The Rookie and the launch of its spinoff, The Rookie North.

Kat Dennings returns as Riley, Jesse Williams and Jenna Elfman are back, and Beth Behrs joins as a guest star playing an ER doctor.

Showrunner Michelle Nader said the Season 2 finale's love-triangle ending shifted during production because of the chemistry between Williams and Dennings on screen.

Shifting Gears is not an isolated success story for ABC.

The network has leaned on traditional, family-built comedies and procedurals across its whole schedule while other networks chase prestige antihero dramas instead.

Hollywood Said Family Comedy Was Dead and Tim Allen Proved Otherwise

Broadcast networks chased streaming money for several seasons, and hour-long dramas filled the slots sitcoms used to hold.

Shifting Gears is proof the audience never left.

Hollywood just stopped making shows for them.

Tim Allen built his career on the same formula twice now.

Write stories about an ordinary family, let the jokes come from real life, and skip the politics.

That formula got Last Man Standing canceled in 2017.

It is the same formula that just earned ABC a third season to produce.

Fox canceled Going Dutch this year after it averaged fewer than two million live viewers a week.

NBC canceled Stumbled the same year, after trade reports named it one of the least-watched scripted shows on the entire network.

CBS killed both DMV and Watson in that same stretch, with CBS president Amy Reisenbach saying the bar for survival keeps rising every season.

Shifting Gears pulled nearly 17 million viewers to its premiere alone, more than eight times the audience that got Going Dutch canceled.

Streaming services pushed one idea for a decade: broadcast comedy was dying, and only prestige dramas were worth funding.

ABC bet the opposite way, building a season around ordinary families instead of a single flashy gamble, and the ratings are the receipt.

Tim Allen is the clearest proof of which bet paid off.

He got pushed off one network for being too much himself, and the next one is building its whole season around the fact that he still is.

Sources:

  • TheWrap, "'Shifting Gears' With Tim Allen Becomes ABC's Best Series Launch in 6 Years With 17 Million Viewers," TheWrap, January 2025.
  • TheWrap, "'Shifting Gears' Season 2 Finale Revs Up Biggest Audience Since Fall Premiere With 6.9 Million Viewers," TheWrap, February 2026.
  • Movieguide, "Tim Allen's Shifting Gears Locks in Season 3 Premiere Date," Movieguide, November 2026.
  • Lauren DeBellis Appell, "'Last Man Standing' – The Show Hollywood's Political Correctness Couldn't Kill Off," Fox News, August 10, 2018.
  • EntertainmentNow, "Sitcoms Canceled by Fox, NBC and CBS in 2026 So Far," EntertainmentNow, 2026.

You may also like...